, Special report No 7/93 concerning controls of irregularities and fraud in the agricultur…

In forcesince 9 Dec 1993
–

the audit methodology;

–

the audit scope;

–

the follow up of audit results;

–

the information and tools available to auditors.

(b)at the Commission

–

the evaluation of Member States' annual programmes;

–

the coordination of control of supra-national undertakings;

–

the evaluation of the application of the regulation;

–

the follow up of audit results.

1.10. As well as evaluating Member States' implementation of the Regulation and the Commission's role in the monitoring thereof, this report also takes into account the findings of the Court's audit of major beneficiaries of export refunds on milk products.

1.11. In its Annual Report 1987(4) () and in two Special Reports No 2/90(5) () and No 2/92(6) () the Court has made observations on export refunds. These observations identified many weaknesses on the part of Member States in relation to:

–

auditee selection;

–

audit frequency;

–

audit scope;

–

audit methodology;

–

selection of transactions for audit;

–

control of large/supra national claimants;

–

information & tools available to auditors;

–

training & qualifications of auditors;

–

follow up of results;

–

coordination of audits;

–

sanctions;

–

powers of scrutineers.

2.

AUDIT FINDINGS: MEMBER STATES

Selection of undertakings for scrutiny programmes

Procedure

2.1. Article 2.2 of the Regulation stipulates that undertakings whose total receipts or payments exceeded 200 000 ECU in the year preceding the year of scrutiny should be scrutinized not less frequently than once every two years. It further provides for a minimum number of undertakings to be scrutinized each year. For the reasons explained below, the application of this rule leads to inadequate audit coverage of the larger concerns as illustrated in Table 2 which gives a breakdown, for the United Kingdom, of the distribution of payments of export refunds by undertaking.