in no Member State was the Customs laboratory systematically consulted for test results on products exported by the undertakings concerned.
2.53. Even where there is provision for consultation, such as in Italy, where the scrutineers consult the Guardia di Finanza to ascertain details on fraud investigations of the undertakings to be scrutinized, it does not always lead to a prompt investigation as the following case illustrates.
2.54. On 31.8.1989, the Court informed the Italian Corte dei Conti of a potential irregularity case involving exports of Pecorino cheese. On 22.12.1989 the Court discussed the case with the Guardia di Finanza in Rome who had no progress to report. A scrutiny was carried out under Regulation (EEC) No 4045/89 by Italian Customs on the undertaking and some of the transactions concerned on 25.3.1991. The scrutineers had no knowledge of the suspected irregularity and, without examining production records, found all claims to be legal and regular. Only on 31.7.1991 did the Guardia di Finanza in Rome send a request to the Guardia unit responsible for the control of the undertaking concerned asking them to effect an investigation. The Guardia found the claims to be irregular and the refunds of 15 000 ECU unduly paid in the period 1986 to 1989 were recovered on 4.9.1992.
2.55. It is also interesting to note that the undertaking concerned exported the same type of cheese, produced in Italy, via the Netherlands and claimed refunds there. The Netherlands Customs laboratory tests indicated that the water content was higher than that declared in the refund claim. However there was no contact between the Dutch and Italian services on this and the Dutch did not investigate other export refund claims made by that undertaking in respect of the same product which amounted to 500 000 ECU in 1991.
Selection of transactions
2.56. The Regulation does not stipulate that transactions as such should be selected for scrutiny according to the risk they present. If the selection of undertakings must take into account not only the financial importance of the undertaking in the EAGGF system but also other risk factors, the selection of transactions should also take account of risk factors. In the Court's opinion, the other risk factors to be taken into account for export refund transactions, should at least be the same as those used for the selection of undertakings, as described at paragraph 2.8 above.
2.57. The Court found that: