, Special report No 7/93 concerning controls of irregularities and fraud in the agricultur…

In forcesince 9 Dec 1993
–

the communication to the Commission of the names of undertakings in receipt of EAGGF funds which are established in third countries.

2.24. There is a need to strengthen Article 7 to provide for the following:

–

mutual assistance covering all the scenarios described at paragraph 2.22;

–

coordination of scrutinies of undertakings concerned;

–

an obligation on a Member State receiving a mutual assistance notification without a request for scrutiny, nevertheless to consider the undertaking and transactions concerned for scrutiny.

2.25. The succeeding paragraphs detail the Court's observations on the implementation by Member States of Article 7. (See also paragraphs 3.12 and 3.13)

Inclusion of payments notified in the scrutiny population

2.26. In all Member States, unless there has been a specific request for a scrutiny, the notifications are filed without action, even when the undertakings concerned have been included in the annual scrutiny programme. This has led to lack of control as illustrated by the following cases:

–

Italy received a notification from Germany in respect of payments to an Italian undertaking totalling 5 Mio ECU. The undertaking was included in the Italian programme in respect of payments in Italy totalling 500 000 ECU but the records in Italy relating to the product for which payments were made in Germany were not audited by the Italian administration;

–

France received a notification from Belgium concerning a French undertaking which had received 3 Mio ECU in 1991. Because this undertaking did not claim any EAGGF funds in France, it was not registered with the French Customs administration. The notification was filed with the comment 'unknown' and no further action was taken. The undertaking concerned was the principle actor in the irregularity described in paragraphs 2.33 to 2.38 of this report(9) ();

–

Ireland received notifications from the Netherlands in respect of an Irish undertaking in receipt of amounts of 130 Mio ECU and 12 Mio ECU but neither amount was included in Ireland's scrutiny;

–

a notification to Germany by France concerning payments of 15 Mio ECU was ignored. These payments were also the subject of the request by the Commission referred to in paragraph 3.12 below;