, Special report No 7/93 concerning controls of irregularities and fraud in the agricultur…

In forcesince 9 Dec 1993

2.16. The history of a trader's compliance with the rules of the EAGGF regimes, is an important criterion in the selection of undertakings for scrutiny. Such information is frequently held by administrations or divisions not responsible for scrutiny. For example, Customs will hold details of irregularities arising from physical controls carried out under Commission Regulation (EEC) No 386/90(7) (); Customs or state laboratories will hold information on laboratory analyses of products subject to export refund claims; paying agencies will have information on irregularities discovered during their prepayment documentary controls or by their internal auditors; Customs or Ministry of Agriculture fraud investigation services will have knowledge of established and/or suspected fraudulent undertakings as well as details of how frauds have been perpetrated; Ministry of Agriculture officials responsible for food and hygiene standards in production plants will have information on an undertaking's record of compliance.

2.17. To gather all such intelligence within the department responsible for the selection of undertakings for scrutiny may be difficult. Nevertheless, it is possible as evidenced by the United Kingdom database which includes most of the abovementioned information. However, there was no evidence to demonstrate that it had been used during the selection procedure. In Italy and France, in contrast, none of the information was available. In other Member States, the information available in scrutiny departments was very limited. In any event, the only example of the use of appropriate intelligence for risk analysis was that found in the Netherlands which is referred to in paragraph 2.11.

Scrutineers' Risk Assessment

2.18. Risks arising from the complexity of the business structure of an undertaking and the adequacy of its records, as well as the results of former scrutinies are all essential elements for the selection of undertakings to be scrutinized. Such information should be available as a result of previous scrutinies. However, apart from the United Kingdom, no Member State has set up procedures to ensure that this information is evaluated by scrutineers and subsequently exploited.

Performance measurement

  • celex=31990R0386