, Special report No 7/93 concerning controls of irregularities and fraud in the agricultur…

In forcesince 9 Dec 1993

2.41. Any request for a scrutiny should naturally receive a reply, preferably in the form of a written report. The United Kingdom and Ireland were the only Member States systematically providing copies of the relevant scrutiny reports.

2.42. No Member State had set up a follow up procedure to ensure that their requests were satisfactorily dealt with.

2.43. The Court considers that Member States have taken a rather minimal approach with regard to the application of Article 7 of the Regulation. For it to be fully effective a more dynamic approach on the part of Member States is needed.

Undertakings with commercial records outside the EC

2.44. The Regulation is silent in respect of the production of the records of undertakings who maintain part or all of the commercial records necessary for scrutiny outside the geographical territory of the EC.

2.45. One of the biggest recipients of export refunds in respect of milk products, operating in all Member States sells 80 % of its exports of EC produce to third countries, via a central company established outside the EC. This company maintains at its location outside the EC the records of settlement by third country customers, the records of complaints concerning goods claimed to be not sound fair and marketable and records of shipping and insurance claims. This fact had been noted in several Member State scrutiny reports.

2.46. In view of the location outside the Community of this central selling company a full scrutiny of all required commercial records relating to refund claims was not made by the Member States concerned.

2.47. The Court sought to undertake an audit of this company with the aim of examining, in particular, commercial evidence relating to the criteria of the sound and fair marketable quality and the placing on the market, of the goods in question. After negotiation, the company accepted the reasonableness of the Court's request and, an authorization for the audit having been obtained from the Government of the third country concerned, the Court conducted an audit. Some findings from this audit are set out in paragraph 2.72.

2.48. Existing legislation is defective in that it does not specifically oblige beneficiaries, as a condition of payment of EAGGF funds, to allow full access to Member States and Community Institutions to relevant commercial records, wherever they may be located. This weakness needs to be remedied so as to avoid any doubts concerning rights of audit.

Scrutiny preparation

  • celex=31980R3183