, Special report No 7/93 concerning controls of irregularities and fraud in the agricultur…

In forcesince 9 Dec 1993

2.61. Contrary to the broad audit scope defined by the Regulation, the Court found that in practice the Member States' approach was unduly limited. Examples of weaknesses in audit scope are cited in the following paragraphs. They are grouped according to the refund criterion which should be tested, with a brief explanation as to the importance of the test.

Export refund classification

2.62. Export refund rates are differentiated according to composition and description as defined in the export refund nomenclature. These compositional requirements relate to the raw materials and to the chemical characteristics of the finished product such as water content or fat content in dry matter. For example, a cheddar cheese with a fat content in dry matter of 48 % or more attracts a refund of 150 ECU maximum per 100 kg whereas if the fat content in dry matter is 47.9 % or less it attracts no refund at all. Rate differentiation on the basis of description and/or composition is common to milk, beef and cereals export refunds.

2.63. Commercial documentation in the limited sense of orders, contracts, delivery notes,freight documents and invoices certainly gives some assurance as to the correct description of the product declared. However, none of those sources will provide adequate assurance as to the raw materials used in its manufacture or of the chemical composition in terms of water content, fat content etc. In order to verify these elements the scrutiny has to include the undertaking's production records and the results of quality control tests on the finished product.

2.64. The Court found that the scrutiny of production and quality control records was carried out systematically in only two Member States, France and Ireland. In Italy, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom, these records were never examined by the scrutiny unit. In Germany and Denmark, they were rarely examined. In these circumstances there can be no assurance that the scrutiny of export refund transactions has adequately covered crucial elements relating to export refund classifications.

2.65. The importance of examining production and quality control records has been illustrated in Special Report No 2/92(11) () and the following example is a further illustration of the importance of such examinations or scrutinies: