, Special report No 7/93 concerning controls of irregularities and fraud in the agricultur…

In forcesince 9 Dec 1993
–

85 tonnes of whole milk powder destroyed by public health authorities in the third country, because the goods were unfit for human consumption resulting from inadequate sealing of cans;

–

617 tonnes of sweetened condensed milk sold for industrial use at 50 % reduction because the viscosity was too thick for the market as a result of a manufacturing fault;

–

42 tonnes of cream seized and destroyed by the public health authority because the goods were unfit for human consumption as a result of bitter taste caused by inadequate sterilization;

–

9,5 tonnes of cream completely destroyed during a storm at sea and

–

1 690 tonnes of whole milk deemed by the customer to be of abnormal quality as a result of its mouldy flavour and therefore not marketable in its existing condition.

The refunds at stake in the abovementioned cases amount to 2,65 Mio ECU.

3.

THE ROLE OF THE COMMISSION

Introductory remarks

3.1. The Commission's reply indicates that, subsequent to the start of the Court's audit, it has undertaken its own exercise to monitor the implementation of Regulation (EEC) No 4045/89. The Court notes with satisfaction that account has been taken of the Court's observations and recommendations in Special Report No 2/92, as well as of the observation which arose during the Courts audit on the implementation of Regulation (EEC) No 4045/89.

Annual programmes

3.2. Article 10.2 of the Regulation obliges Member States to send to the Commission their annual programmes identifying the numbers of undertakings to be scrutinized and their breakdown by sector on the basis of the amounts received and the criteria adopted for drawing up the programme. The Commission must make known its comments within 6 weeks and if there are none, the programmes are to be implemented as established.

3.3. At the time of the Court's audit at the Commission, the Member States' annual programmes for the years 1990/91,1991/92, 1992/93 had been received. The Commission's action on receipt of the programmes has been limited to an arithmetical check on the calculation of the numbers of undertakings to be scrutinized. The only query raised was in respect of the United Kingdom 1990/91 programme. There has been no evaluation of the programmes in terms of the risk criteria used for the selection of undertakings.

  • celex=31989R4045