, Special report No 7/93 concerning controls of irregularities and fraud in the agricultur…

In forcesince 9 Dec 1993

1.3. Member States are responsible for the preparation of annual programmes of undertakings to be scrutinized; for the execution of the scrutinies; and for the preparation of annual reports on the application of the Regulation.

1.4. Provision is made in Article 7 for mutual assistance between Member States in the control of undertakings established in a Member State other than that in which the payment was made and for the regular notification of such payments.

1.5. Part of the Commission's supervisory and coordinating role under the Regulation is to ensure that the annual scrutiny programmes are adopted on the basis of appropriate criteria. (See Chapters 2 and 3)

1.6. The Court has audited the implementation of Regulation (EEC) No 4045/89, which had reached its third annual programme by late 1992.

1.7. The objective of the Court's audit was to evaluate the effectiveness of the Regulation and of the controls carried out thereunder by Member States, with particular reference to export refunds on milk products. The issues examined by the Court were:

(a)the effectiveness of the Regulation as a framework for the a posteriori control of EAGGF income and expenditure;

(b)the effectiveness of the Commission in its supervisory and coordinating role; and

(c)the extent to which Member States have fulfilled their responsibilities under the Regulation in the planning and execution of the required scrutinies.

Table 1 - EAGGF-Guarantee expenditure subject to Regulation (EEC) No 4045/89 scrutiny in 1990 ">Member State"> ID="1"> 0,75"> ID="1"> 0,94"> ID="1"> 4,12"> ID="1"> 1,47"> ID="1"> 1,82"> ID="1"> 5,05"> ID="1"> 0,53"> ID="1"> 3,97"> ID="1"> 0,00"> ID="1"> 2,74"> ID="1"> 0,25"> ID="1"> 1,67"> ID="1">23,31""Source: Commission report on the implementation of Regulation (EEC) No 4045/89. (VI/5202/92)>

1.8. The Court carried out its audit at the Commission and in Denmark, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom, these Member States being the most significant in the whole area of export refund payments. The Court's audit was announced in July 1992. It was completed at the Commission on the 14 September 1992 and in the Member States by February 1993.

1.9. The audit focused on:

(a)in the Member States:

–

information available to the unit responsible for preparing the annual scrutiny programme;

–

the criteria used for the selection of undertakings to audit;

–

the coordination of audits including the use of mutual assistance;