2.19. The evaluation of the execution of a scrutiny programme is an integral part of risk analysis. It is important to ascertain whether or not the risk elements identified have resulted in the detection of irregularities so as to use this knowledge in the preparation of succeeding programmes.
2.20. Only the Netherlands had made this type of evaluation and even this, at the time of the Court's audit, was limited to the pilot risk analysis (referred to in paragraph 2.11). The evaluation demonstrated impressive results in that more than 25 % of the scrutinies resulting from the risk analysis gave rise to the discovery of irregularities amounting in value to 1,2 Mio ECU.
2.21. All Member States should evaluate the results of their annual scrutiny programmes against their selection criteria and such evaluations should be included in the annual reports submitted to the Commission under Article 9 of the Regulation.
Control of supra-national undertakings
2.22. The distribution of export refund payments in the dairy sector illustrates how a limited number of undertakings account for the greater part of the refund payments. There is a similar pattern in other product sectors. Computerized information received by the Court from 8 Member States, shows that in the dairy sector some 25 undertakings or groups of undertakings account for 60 % of the refunds. Most of these undertakings operate in more than one Member State. The following scenarios exist:
undertakings receive payments in a Member State other than the one in which they are established;
they receive such payments via 'brass plate'(8) () companies;
they have their own separate registered companies within the Member State making the payments but some, if not all, of their commercial records are maintained outside that state;
the production takes place in a Member State other than that where payment is received;
some of their commercial records are maintained outside the Community.
2.23. Article 7 of the Regulation provides for:
mutual assistance between Member States for scrutiny purposes, on request, where an undertaking is established in a Member State other than the one in which the payments are made;
the notification of such payments annually from the Member State making the payment to the one in which the undertaking is established, with a copy being sent to the Commission; and