2.3. The effect of Article 2.2 has also been counterproductive in terms of scrutiny quality. In the United Kingdom the normal duration of a scrutiny was found to be only one day. The audit effort on the spot accorded to the two main recipients accounting for 41 % and 22 % respectively of milk refunds paid in the 1990/91 EAGGF year was only 6 man days each whereas that devoted to undertakings in receipt of a total of less than 1 % was 14 man days.
2.4. The distribution of refund payments among beneficiaries as illustrated by the United Kingdom example is representative of the pattern in all market sectors across all Member States.
2.5. Article 2.1 provides for the financial importance of an undertaking and other risk factors to be taken into account selection procedures. In recent years, the use of risk analysis in audit techniques has been widely developed in both the private and public sectors. It has now become an essential tool in the selection of activities and undertakings for audit coverage and has been used with increasing effectiveness in auditing areas such as tax administration, particularly in relation to Value Added Tax.
2.6. Risk analysis applies a weighting to the expenditure in accordance with the risks identified. An illustration of the importance of selecting products where small variations in composition can have considerable financial consequences is given in Table 3 below which shows, in relation to the most important milk products exported from a Member State during the EAGGF year 1989, the percentage reduction in refunds which would have resulted had there been a failure, even a minor one, to meet classification requirements.
2.7. There are also risks attendant on the fact that certain export refunds are differentiated by destination. For example refunds paid in respect of an export of Provolone cheese to the USA, where the refund rate is 160 ECU per 100 kg, present a higher risk than refunds paid on the same cheese exported to Canada for which the refund rate is 120 ECU per 100 kg, particularly where the goods destined for the USA are routed via the St Lawrence Seaway which gives easy access to both Canada and the USA.
2.8. Risk analysis should apply to all EAGGF measures, taking account of such factors as:
previous scrutiny coverage and results;
product risk;
destination risk;
financial importance;
complexity of the undertaking's business structure and activities; and
history of known or suspected irregularities.