, Special report No 7/93 concerning controls of irregularities and fraud in the agricultur…

In forcesince 9 Dec 1993

3.4. Article 10.5 allows the Commission to request the inclusion of a particular category of undertaking in the Member States' programmes. The Commission has made two such requests, addressed to all Member States, to include export refunds on beef and export refunds and production aid for olive oil in the 1992/93 programme. However, there was no evidence of follow up at the Commission to ensure that these requests were respected.

3.5. Within the Commission, the Directorate-General for Agriculture (DG VI) is responsible for administering the Regulation. Despite the fact that other Commission services, such as the 'Unité de Coordination de la Lutte Anti Fraude' (UCLAF), the Financial Controller (DG XX) and the Customs Directorate (DG XXI), hold information on irregularities and fraud trends none of these services is consulted by DG VI when considering the Member States' scrutiny programmes.

Annual report

3.6. Article 9 of the Regulation obliges Member States to send the Commission a detailed report each year on the application of the Regulation.

3.7. The first annual programme under Regulation (EEC) No 4045/89 ran from 1.7.1990 to 30.6.1991. Member States were obliged under article 9(1) of the Regulation to submit their reports on the application of the Regulation by 1 January 1992. Under article 9(5), the Commission was obliged to submit its report on the application of the Regulation by 31 December 1991. There is moreover no provision in the Regulation which makes the Commission's report dependent on the prior receipt of Member States' reports. At the time of the audit in September 1992, the Commission had not submitted the required report. It was later submitted in December 1992(13) ().

3.8. At the time of the audit, no internal Commission documentation was made available to the Court to indicate that Member States' reports had been evaluated other than tables comparing the numbers of scrutinies required by Article 2.2 with those executed.

3.9. The Commission is obliged in its annual report to evaluate the progress achieved on the administration of funds referred to in Article 10 of Council Regulation (EEC) No 729/70(14) ().

  • celex=31970R0729
  • celex=31989R4045