, Special report No 7/93 concerning controls of irregularities and fraud in the agricultur…

In forcesince 9 Dec 1993

2.9. The main purpose of using risk analysis is to provide the most effective basis possible on which to select the most interesting undertakings for scrutiny having regard to the overriding need to prevent and deal with irregularities. Analysis is also helpful in determining the audit effort required to carry out an adequate scrutiny of each undertaking and the desirable frequency of scrutiny.

2.10. No Member State had set up a procedure to include all the above elements. In Denmark, France, Ireland, Italy and the United Kingdom, apart from the obligatory scrutinies of undertakings in receipt of more than 200 000 ECU, the only additional criteria taken into account systematically in the selection procedure, were financial importance and previous audit coverage. In no Member State was there any advance calculation by undertaking of the audit effort required. The only advance planning was in respect of the quantitive obligations contained in article 2.2.

2.11. Only in Germany and the Netherlands, is a certain amount of risk analysis carried out:

–

In Germany, for export refunds, data is interrogated in order to identify undertakings dealing in 'risk' products for consideration in the annual scrutiny programme. The authorities, however, were unable to supply an explanation of their risk criteria.

Table 3 - Percentage reduction in Refund rates resulting from classification requirement failures ">Product"> ID="1">147> ID="2"> 30> ID="3">30> ID="4">f/c failure = 2.5 % reduction in rate"> ID="1">143> ID="2"> 29> ID="3">59> ID="4">Added whey etc. = reduction based on quantity added"> ID="1">47> ID="2"> 9> ID="3">68> ID="4">f/c fallure = 1 % reduction in rate"> ID="1">37> ID="2"> 7> ID="3">75> ID="4">f/c failure = 10 % reduction in rate"> ID="1">15> ID="2"> 3> ID="3">78> ID="4">f/c failure = 20 % reduction in rate"> ID="1">14> ID="2"> 3> ID="3">81> ID="4">f/c failure = 20 % reduction in rate"> ID="1">13> ID="2"> 3> ID="3">84> ID="4">f/c failure = 30 % reduction in rate"> ID="1">12> ID="2"> 2> ID="3">86> ID="4">f/c failure = 100 % reduction in rate""key: f/c = fat content

fcdm = fat content in dry matter

Source: Analysis by the Court of Auditors of Export Refund data supplied by a Member State 1989/1990.>