Payment information
2.49. The scrutineers need to have the details underlying the transactions they are to scrutinize, in a form easy to interrogate for the purposes of selecting transactions. They should also be available for consultation on the undertakings' premises.
2.50. In all Member States except Denmark and partly in Germany, the payment details such as claim number, date, product, quantity, destination, rate, and amount were not available to scrutineers in such a form. The Court found that:
in Italy, the scrutineers were advised by the scrutiny central unit, of the total annual amount paid to the undertaking. They then had to reconstruct the claim details by requesting the undertaking to provide a summary identifying all the export declarations and then requesting the Customs offices where they had been lodged to forward copies;
in Ireland, the scrutineers had to examine and, where necessary, copy details manually from the claim documents at the paying agency;
in the Netherlands, the United Kingdom and for most part of Germany, details were available only in the form of computer listings, which are very difficult to use for the purpose of risk analysis; and
in France, claim details were not obtained from the paying agencies by the Customs but from their own export statistics database in the form of a computer listing based on only the 8 digits of the Combined Customs Nomenclature in spite of the fact that refunds are differentiated by 3 additional digits under the export refund nomenclature (see also paragraph 2.62). Furthermore, the rate and amount of the refund were unavailable within the Customs data base.
Background information
2.51. The preparation for any scrutiny should always include researching the information held by other official entities involved in the control of EAGGF funds such as that described in paragraph 2.16 above. It should cover paying agencies' correspondence with undertakings concerning the regularity of claims, problems over proofs of arrival, refund classification and other issues. Details of analysis results held by Customs laboratories should be studied as should the reports of fraud investigation services on known and/or suspected frauds.
2.52. The Court found that:
in the scrutiny preparation process the above information was not obtained by the scrutiny unit from the paying agencies in any Member State; and