, Special report No 7/93 concerning controls of irregularities and fraud in the agricultur…

In forcesince 9 Dec 1993

a Customs laboratory test on a sample of Mozzarella cheese exported from the United Kingdom with refunds, showed that the product had an excessive water content and should be reclassified, thus attracting a lower rate of refund. The case was treated as a fraud investigation by United Kingdom Customs. The investigation unit responsible obtained the undertaking's own laboratory test results on the product in question which supported the Customs test results and also established that the misdeclaration related to many other transactions. The irregularity amounted to 900 000 ECU which was recovered along with a penalty.

2.66. Article 3 of the Regulation provides for physical checks on the quantity and nature of stocks. Physical inspections are important for the following reasons:

–

it is a basic check as to whether or not the undertaking has the capacity to manufacture the goods in question;

–

it enables the scrutineer to identify key control documents which indicate and quantify ingredients;

–

it enables the scrutineer to check key control procedures such as the method of establishing quantity and

–

it enables the scrutineer to identify, and therefore follow up the use of, raw materials.

2.67. The Court found that physical inspections of production, storage and despatch premises were not systematically considered for inclusion in any of the Member State scrutinies. The Court's own audit of export refund beneficiaries has proved the usefulness of such checks.

–

plastic wrapping included in the weight for refund purposes (40 000 ECU per year overpaid to one refund claimant);

–

buttermilk used instead of skimmed milk resulting in overpayments of 1,2 Mio ECU;

–

additives such as casein and whey not deducted from the weight for refund purposes with corresponding overpayments of 800 000 ECU. This case, which had not been detected by national audits in 4 Member States (F, UK, NL and D), was the subject of voluntary disclosure by the undertaking concerned.

Sound and fair marketable quality and placing of goods on the market

  • celex=31989R4045