, Special report No 7/93 concerning controls of irregularities and fraud in the agricultur…

In forcesince 9 Dec 1993
–

In the Netherlands, there is an exercise in its third year, whereby a limited range of export refund classifications is analysed. The analysis takes account of the risks presented by the export refund classification, known risk destinations, known fraud methods, Customs' laboratory analysis results, trading patterns and company links. The companies identified by this analysis are included in the annual scrutiny programme. An explanation of the risks and the records needed to detect irregularities associated with these risks, are communicated to the scrutineers.

2.12. Notwithstanding the German and Netherlands' effort, the Court considers that general lack of effective risk analysis in the Member States constitutes a serious weakness in scrutiny procedures.

Information used in the selection of undertakings

Export Refund Payment Data

2.13. Payment information must be available in an easily accessible form to permit the identification of undertakings dealing in risk products and exporting to risk destinations so that the undertakings to be scrutinized can be most efficiently selected. The Court has received and used such data on magnetic tapes from all of the abovementioned Member States, except Ireland, annually since 1989. There are thus no valid technical reasons why Member States should not have made swifter progress in using such data in planning scrutinies of undertakings.

2.14. In the Member States audited (see paragraph 1.8) the Court found the following:

(a)in Denmark, France, Italy and the United Kingdom, the payment data is captured but not interrogated by the unit responsible for drawing up the annual scrutiny programme;

(b)in Germany and the Netherlands, the key payment data is available and used, albeit to a limited extent and;

(c)Ireland does not at present capture key data by refund claim but the feasibility of doing so is being examined by the authorities.

2.15. The basic data concerning export refund payments, which the Court considers should be captured by paying agencies and made available to the departments responsible for the planning of scrutinies for use by them in selecting undertakings and transactions, is identified in annex 1 to this report.

Information on Irregularities and Frauds