Recital 40, Decision_act (EU) 2002/195

In forcesince 17 Oct 2001

The only case in which retrospective aid could be granted in the light of the guidelines, once it had been found to be compatible with the rules of the relevant common market organisation, is that of schemes which are compensatory in nature. In the case in point, it must therefore be ascertained whether point 11 of the guidelines, concerning "aids to compensate for damage to agricultural production or the means of agricultural production", in this specific case aid intended to compensate farmers for losses resulting from bad weather (the drought in 1988 to 90), is applicable. In fact, in their letter No 3899 of 12 June 1997, the Italian authorities linked the failure to use the replanting rights (and therefore the losses suffered) with the drought. Point 11.1.2 of the guidelines nevertheless stipulates that, in order to avoid a risk of distorting the conditions of competition, the Commission considers it important to ensure that, subject to administrative and budgetary constraints, aid to compensate farmers for damage caused to agricultural production is paid as soon as possible after the occurrence of the adverse event concerned. Where aid is paid only several years after the occurrence of the event in question, there is a real danger that the payment of such aid will produce the same economic effects as operating aid. This is particularly the case where aid is paid retrospectively in respect of claims which were not properly documented at the time. Therefore, in the absence of a specific justification, resulting for example from the nature and extent of the event, or the delayed or continuing nature of the damage, the Commission will not approve proposals for aid which are submitted more than three years after the occurrence of the event. In the case in point, that period has expired and the authorities have provided no information with which to analyse the nature and extent of the event, or the delayed or continuing effect of the damage, which could justify extending the three-year deadline laid down in the guidelines.