Volkswagen knew that the measures aimed to or at least were liable to obstruct parallel exports of vehicles from Italy by final consumers, and intermediaries, and restrict competition. Volkswagen was also aware that its behaviour was infringing Article 85. This is evident from the internal memo 'Reimporte Italien` (Reimports from Italy) of 23 February 1995 (see footnote 80). According to this, Volkswagen was aware of the effect of the margins policy and regarded the scheme itself as 'very likely to attract a fine`. The deliberate nature of this policy can be seen further in the measures for monitoring and penalising dealers. A memo from Audi (see footnote 17) states that it would be 'somewhat risky` to 'connect` the measures taken in Italy 'with the obstruction of reimports. . .`, and suggests that the measures 'should be communicated orally between the regions`. In addition, the documents concerning or connected with the export ban/restriction were always classified as 'confidential` or 'highly confidential` (see Chapter 1, C.II.1.(b) and the documents referred to in footnotes 74 to 77). Altogether, it can be concluded from this that Volkswagen has committed the infringement against Article 85(1) deliberately (166).
Recital 214, Decision_act (EU) 1998/273
In forcesince 28 Jan 1998