Recital 144, Decision_act (EU) 1998/273

In forcesince 28 Jan 1998

The effect of the measures is to restrict cross-border sales of vehicles. Authorised dealers were repeatedly told that they were free to sell vehicles only within their contract territories (see the letter Measures to control and prevent re-export dated 26 September 1994, mentioned in footnote 15 and referred to in Chapter 1, Section C.I; see also the document referred to in footnote 18 cited in Chapter 1, Section C.I). If they failed to comply, they were told to expect penalties. Dealers complied with Autogerma's instructions and refrained from sales to customers resident outside their contract territory, drawing no distinction between customers who were final consumers, intermediaries acting on behalf of such consumers, other authorised dealers forming part of the distribution network, or independent dealers outside that network. Chapter 1, Section D shows that authorised dealers have refused to sell consumers VW or Audi vehicles on the grounds that the manufacturers or main importers had prohibited exports (see the documents referred to in Chapter 1, Section D.I and footnotes 130, 132, 134, 135, 136, 138 and 140). Authorised dealers have frequently refused to make sales to consumers on the ground that if they sold for export, there would be reprisals on the part of the main importer (loc. cit. and footnote 137), and indeed that their dealership contract might be terminated (loc. cit. and footnote 132). Authorised dealers responded to enquiries from outside their contract territory by a standard letter, even when the enquiries obviously came from final consumers; in that letter, they advised the customer not to purchase from them because of the long delivery time (see the documents referred to in Chapter 1, Section D.III footnotes 145 and 147). A document in the Commission's possession shows that an authorised dealer attempted to buy back a vehicle supplied to a final consumer resident outside his contract territory, and in giving an account of this to Autogerma apologised for the inconvenience caused to the manufacturer by the sale (see the document referred to in Chapter 1, Section D.III and footnote 144).