Even if it were considered that the principle of proportionality should apply, the Commission considers that German measures are not disproportionate. Firstly, it is not the case that the German measures are unnecessary. On the contrary, the lengthy negotiations between Germany and Switzerland over the years appears to be proof that measures are indeed necessary although Switzerland does advance that in the current situation noise levels in Germany do not exceed "valid noise limits". However, noise limits must be considered maximum acceptable thresholds, not comfort levels. Member States are in principle free to take measures to lower noise levels below these limits depending on local circumstances. As Germany has pointed out, the German area overflown by planes approaching Zurich is an important tourist destination and as such particularly vulnerable to noise emissions. Furthermore, the German measures concern mostly early morning and late evening hours, when noise sensitivity is particularly high.
Recital 42, Decision_act (EU) 2004/12
In forcesince 5 Dec 2003cited 1×
Judgment of the General Court (Fifth Chamber) of 9 September 2010. Confédération suisse v European Commission.Decision
In the present case, with regard, first, to the possible existence of an objective justification for the adoption of the measures at issue in regard solely to Zurich airport, it must be recalled that, according to recital 42 in the …
9 Sep 2010 · 62005TJ0319