, Special Report No 15/2000 on the Cohesion Fund, together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 6 Jul 2000
15.

In addition, under a framework agreement signed on 15 December 1994 covering the entire duration of the CF Regulation, the Commission may, if necessary, invite the EIB to assist in the evaluation at the technical and financial level, in order to assist the Commission in the examination of projects and help to achieve the best combination of sources of finance.

Deficiencies in the guidelines relating to applications for assistance

16.

Desk audits of the case files in the relevant Commission offices showed that the essential elements stipulated by the Regulation (on which the individual decisions were based) were not always on file and that the cost-effectiveness, cost/performance and impact analyses in respect of the project had not been drawn up systematically since no precise instructions concerning the methods to be followed had been included in the form provided for this purpose. Likewise, alternatives to the project had not always been studied and taken into consideration.

17.

For this reason, in the case of some actions within the framework of the four groups of projects audited in Spain, the Commission was not always aware of the details (as far as the locality and the amounts involved were concerned).

18.

In Portugal, analysis of the costs and benefits associated with an infrastructure project did not produce any insight into the economic and social returns. In the case of another application for assistance in the field of the environment the potential receipts were not taken into account as the Commission concluded, without conducting a financial analysis, that it was impossible to establish a link between the receipts collected by the beneficiary company, a commercial water company, and its investment, financed by the CF, which mainly consisted of replacing worn and sometimes leaking water pipes in the network. Although there are no provisions on this in the current Regulation (792/93), on the basis of which the project was financed, in certain cases the Commission could usefully have taken potential revenue into account in its analysis.