, Special Report No 15/2000 on the Cohesion Fund, together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 6 Jul 2000
87.

If the Commission finds the CBA insufficient or unconvincing it may ask the Member States to provide additional information or to extend the analysis, and this may lead to a redefinition of the projects in question or, even, ultimately to a refusal of Community funding for certain projects. For example, projects such as the Gran Porto drinking water supply or the Enxoé (Portugal) dam were rescaled following the extension of the CBA.

88.

Examination of the CBAs showed that despite the Commission's efforts in the matter (notably the publication in June 1997 of a guide to the analysis of the costs and benefits of large-scale projects within the Community regional framework), the treatment and calculation of socioeconomic variables can differ widely between promoters within the same sectoral field and the same Member State.

89.

Basic CBA concepts (net present value, internal rate of return, discount rate, constant or current prices, tax aspects, sensitivity analysis(8), etc.) are not always understood in the same way by the parties concerned. External factors are often insufficiently evaluated and quantified. Evaluating the feasibility, risks or alternative options is rarely considered. The socioeconomic costs or benefits are sometimes incomplete and sometimes only the financial aspects are taken into account. Moreover the CBAs do not always include precise and detailed information that would make it possible to verify, amongst other things, their reliability.