, Special Report No 15/2000 on the Cohesion Fund, together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 6 Jul 2000
38.

The CF may contribute to the financing of projects or stages of projects which are technically and financially independent or groups of projects linked to a visible strategy which form a coherent whole. In any event, the total cost of a project or group of projects may not, in principle, be less than EUR 10 million. This definition of a project has met with difficulties with regard to its interpretation and application, especially in the field of the environment where the projects are traditionally on a smaller scale and sometimes more complex in conception than those in the field of transport infrastructure. In the field of the environment, the Commission gave general approval to groups of projects in Spain and Greece but did not always first identify all the components of the subprojects. These components, and sometimes the more specific provisions linked to the project, such as the timetable or the estimated costs as well, subsequently had to be clarified by the national authorities responsible.

39.

In Ireland, some projects (Dublin ring Road, N3-N1 section of the Northern Cross, Belview harbour, etc.) had already received Community finance, within the Structural Funds framework, for preliminary studies, work or previously completed parts of projects, before receiving CF assistance in the field of infrastructure, even though the project or stage of the project was not clearly identified. The Irish Belview harbour project was split into four independent projects, each of them below the EUR 10 million threshold stipulated in Article 10(3) of the Regulation and each of them therefore required a separate cost-benefit study whereas an ex ante evaluation covering the four projects would have been appropriate.

40.

In Greece and Portugal certain projects first received Community financing from the Structural Funds, especially Envireg, then received CF assistance even though it was not possible to identify the stages of the project concerned clearly on the financial and technical level. Often the expenditure co-financed by Envireg and by the CF was based on the same contract and the same schedule for its physical and financial completion had been laid down in the specifications, which made no distinction between the sources of Community finance.