The development of a project financed by the CF occurs in several stages and the Commission intervenes mainly in the initial and final phases. The intermediate stages and their financial consequences would merit more rigorous management, in partnership. The Court's checks revealed a number of anomalies in respect of eligibility and accounting for expenditure and also the finalisation of projects. The Commission should devote more resources to on-the-spot checks in order to detect weaknesses in the management systems (see paragraphs 51 to 70).
For the evaluation of the CF, the Commission called in a consultant who developed an approach which used various macroeconomic models. In spite of certain limitations, these produce useful results. The Commission should develop this tool further and apply it more fully so that general conclusions can be drawn. At the level of the cohesion countries only Spain and Portugal attempted to evaluate the national impact of, firstly, the CF and, secondly, certain projects (see paragraphs 71 to 84).
The cost-benefit analyses (CBA) performed before approval of the projects are not always prepared with equal rigour and the calculation methods used may vary greatly depending on the managers involved. The indicators are sometimes too broadly defined to evaluate the real impact of the projects, to draw comparisons and to enable reliable measurements to be taken (see paragraphs 85 to 98).
The improvement of the transport infrastructure and of the environment in the beneficiary countries underlines the impact, in terms of quality, of the CF as an instrument of greater economic and social cohesion in the EU. As regards the quantitative aspect, the models used show a positive impact by projects, in terms of jobs, output, income and investment, on the regions concerned and on other regions and on the economy of the beneficiary Member State. They also show, albeit less clearly, a positive impact on cohesion and convergence (see paragraphs 99 to 108).
In view of these encouraging results, the Commission should attempt to concentrate its management on a medium-term planning perspective which would offer more guidance and continuity, and should endeavour to perfect the tools for the macroeconomic evaluation of the projects and of the CF as a whole (see paragraphs 109 to 117).
INTRODUCTION
Description of the Cohesion Fund