, Special Report No 15/2000 on the Cohesion Fund, together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 6 Jul 2000
19.

In Greece, in the field of the environment, the consultants draw up files on applications for assistance and, in particular, compile socioeconomic studies (cost-benefit analyses, calculation of the economic and financial internal rate of return (IRR) and estimation of the project's impact in terms of job creation), often without making visits to the final beneficiary concerned. Within the framework of the checks carried out inconsistencies were discovered, in particular:

–

the existence of potential revenue generated by a project included in the socioeconomic analysis which was not taken into account when fixing the maximum rate of CF assistance,

–

different types of cost are considered to be acceptable by the Commission, in the CBAs, in respect of sectoral projects of the same type. Some allow for handling charges, others do not, without any explanation. Indirect staff costs and operating costs such as electricity may be included in some projects but not in others. For the most part, these data are often overestimated or incorrect,

–

for a project in Kalamata (Greece), the socio-economic study used data from a similar project in Rhodes and at no time was this queried by the parties involved,

–

job-creation estimates submitted in the project applications had sometimes been overestimated or were unrealistic.

20.

Considering the fact that the explanatory and analytical documents included with a project application are not always exhaustive and reliable, the Commission is not always in a position to ensure that the projects proposed are the most effective before authorising them. On the other hand, it was not possible, in the context of the controls carried out, to identify the projects rejected by the Commission or to draw up a list of the main motives for the rejection of projects submitted by the beneficiary Member States.

Coordination between the Cohesion Fund and the ERDF

  • celex=31993R0792