, Special Report No 15/2000 on the Cohesion Fund, together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 6 Jul 2000
48.

The inspections demonstrated that, in certain cases, at the time of the Commission's approval the project was already virtually finished. The submission and approval of projects in the course of completion, or completed, is not consistent with the principle of partnership. This principle involves consultation between the Commission and the authorities responsible at national, regional and local level, which should cover the entire course of the project, or stage of project, including its planning, implementation, any amendments, the completion of the work and its becoming operational. In addition, the Court has already drawn attention to(6) the various repercussions of the two approaches which consist in submitting either new projects or projects in the course of completion; in the first case the time required to complete the projects is greater whereas the second approach allows Community financing to be put to use more rapidly; the two approaches also have different effects in respect of the impact of Community financing, which is less direct in the case of projects already being implemented or completed.

Conditionality

49.

In contrast to Structural Fund aid, financial assistance from the CF is subject to a conditionality clause. Article 6 of the CF Regulation 1164/94 of 16 May 1994 makes the co-financing of new projects or of new stages of projects in countries with excessive deficits dependent on the achievement of targets set by Council recommendations in compliance with Article 104C of the Treaty. Application of this principle of conditionality resulted in an examination by the Commission of the budgetary position of CF beneficiary Member States which had excessive deficits. Each of these examinations (in spring in respect of the preceding year, in autumn for the current year) showed that the annual target recommended by the Council in respect of the budget deficit had been achieved. As a result, co-financing from the Cohesion Fund was continued.

50.

In the short term, however, conditionality can make the achievement by the less prosperous Member States of the various macroeconomic objectives difficult. On the one hand, these countries are committed to substantial government investment, as shown in Table 5, in order to reduce the lag in their development and to increase their capacity for growth and prosperity. On the other hand, they must, at the same time, reduce their budget deficit and retain control over their government debt.

Table 5