, Special Report No 15/2000 on the Cohesion Fund, together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 6 Jul 2000
82.

Even though these models (VAR, CGE and MEDD) provide useful and interesting results about the potential impact of CF intervention and thus help towards a better understanding of the related effects, there is no real coordination between the models used. Furthermore, none of the models specifies, for the results obtained, the level of imprecision that is due to the poor quality or availability of the data collected or to the limits of the extrapolation methods used. The Commission did not carry out any reconciliation of the results obtained from these models and did not carry out the necessary harmonisation of them in order to establish overall conclusions in terms of the CF's impact on the economies of the four cohesion countries. The results produced by each model separately are generally positive. It is recommended that the Commission refine this resource for evaluating projects macroeconomically and that it apply it more fully.

Models developed on Member States' initiative

83.

Only Spain has used CF financial support to carry out a study of the overall macroeconomic impact of the CF on the national economy. The approach that was adopted for this study, which was presented in November 1995, was to use three models (Input/output, Moisees and Hermin) (see the Annex).

84.

Portugal carried out specific impact assessments for some major projects, such as the new bridge over the Tagus, using what is essentially an input/output model. The other cohesion countries have not produced any special studies at national or regional level on the macroeconomic impact of projects, or of the CF itself.

Cost-benefit analysis (CBA)

85.

When the projects submitted by the Member States concerned are being examined, cost-benefit analysis is one of the main criteria for the decision on whether to grant Community assistance. The Commission can, if necessary, call on the European Investment Bank to assist in the project evaluation (see paragraph 15). In the field of transport infrastructure the CBAs are usually based on long experience and a well-established methodology which allows, amongst other things, quantification of all the necessary parameters.

86.

In the environment field, on the other hand, the difficulty of quantifying the expected benefits has often led Member States to use methods of a more qualitative and less quantitative nature.