, Special Report No 15/2000 on the Cohesion Fund, together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 6 Jul 2000
103.

Macroeconomic impact evaluation results were obtained using the models mentioned in paragraph 77 (see Table 8), as regards the impact of the projects on the region concerned, on the economy of the Member State and on cohesion and convergence.

Table 8

Main results according to the VAR1, VAR2 and EGC models

Main results according to VAR1 model

>TABLE>

Impact of transport infrastructure projects in Spain for period 1993 to 1999 according to VAR2

>TABLE>

Short, medium and long-term effects of Cohesion Fund projects (CGE models)

>TABLE>

Impact of projects on the region concerned

104.

The positive effects in terms of job creation and unemployment, output and real incomes must be emphasised. The gains in real income that were shown by the CGE model were sometimes substantially lower than those estimated by means of the VAR models (Madrid ring road, Rias Bajas motorway). As regards the investment of private capital, it may be that, depending on the model used, the implementation of the CF project leads to a reduction or an increase in such investment (Rias Bajas motorway in Spain).

Impact of projects on other regions and on the Member State's economy

105.

For individual projects the VAR2 model, which was applied only in Spain, gives the same type of effect for other regions and the whole economy as for the region concerned, in terms of job creation and unemployment, output, real income and investment of private capital. The medium and long-term effects of individual projects, which are estimated by means of the CGE models for the whole economy of the Member State, are also found to be positive. The finding made in paragraph 104 about the consistency of the VAR and CGE models as regards gains in real income also applies as regards the whole economy.

106.

The following are the main conclusions of the evaluation of the overall impact of the CF on the Spanish economy, using the models mentioned in paragraph 83:

(a)

the Leontief input/output model highlights a positive impact of CF investment of around 0,3 % on gross annual added value and states that one job/year is created for ESP 4,23 million (approximately EUR 0,02 million) invested in CF projects, which would be equivalent, on average, to the creation of 40000 jobs per year;

(b)

the Moisees model in turn shows that investment within the CF framework could generate an annual increase in GDP of around 0,1 % which would create the conditions for the creation of approximately 20000 jobs per year;