, Special Report No 15/2000 on the Cohesion Fund, together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 6 Jul 2000
(a)

the Commission alone is responsible for the approval of projects and their implementing provisions and also for the evaluation of the potential and real impact of their implementation and, once they have been completed, it is also the Commission which is responsible for approving the final implementation report. Within this framework, the Commission may draw upon the assistance of experts should it not dispose of such expertise;

(b)

with regard to monitoring and controls, a monitoring committee has been set up for each beneficiary Member State to allow discussion, once or twice a year, of technical questions relating to any amendments to the projects' financing plans or various other matters concerning, amongst other things, intermediate payments;

(c)

eligibility, as defined under Article 3 of the CF Regulation, was also the subject of "principles governing the eligibility of expenditure within the framework of projects supported by the Cohesion Fund". The beneficiary Member States were notified of these principles, which take the distinctive features of this instrument into consideration, in May 1998.

Scope of the audit

5.

The overall objective of the Court's audit was to examine the management by the Commission of the CF, on the one hand, and its implementation in the Member States, on the other. Apart from the legality and regularity of the operations co-financed by the CF, the investigation also included an evaluation of the efficiency and effectiveness of the projects involved and also of the complementarity of CF projects with other structural actions such as the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF). Although it was not the goal of the inquiry to make a direct evaluation of the CF's impact, certain findings are reported which have been noted by experts with regard to the results obtained and the impact produced by the CF. The inquiries were carried out in the Commission's offices and in the four beneficiary Member States. They covered a selection of 37 of the 181 projects which had been closed at the beginning of the year 1998 or were in the process of completion.

IMPLEMENTATION OF THE BUDGET

Financial development