, Special Report No 15/2000 on the Cohesion Fund, together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 6 Jul 2000
72.

In order to be able to satisfy these requirements of the Regulation, the Commission signed two contracts with a consultant. The first, dated 3 July 1995, for an amount of EUR 675965, was for the development of methods of evaluating the macroeconomic impact of CF projects. The second, dated 1 April 1997, for an amount of EUR 283500, essentially concerned the collection of new data to allow new project evaluations.

73.

The specifications for the first contract were based on a feasibility study carried out in 1994 by the same consultant on the same subject and took over the same proposed structure and the same evaluation criteria. The Commission did not consider that this unusual situation posed any problems. Most of the modelling approaches proposed by the various applicants in connection with the call for tenders were already familiar and were all considered by the Commission to be suitable for evaluating project impact, as the Commission had not adopted any special criteria for appraising these approaches. In the end the Commission took the consultant who submitted one of the highest bids and whose approach excelled by virtue of its originality, but had still not been tested in practice as far as its applicability was concerned. A subsequent modification of the first contract is signed, but not dated, and extends by three months the time allowed for performance, so extending the total duration to 15 months. This extension devalues de facto the initial criteria for the awarding of the contract, given that the tender selection procedure had included consideration of tenderers' ability to complete the study within the time allowed and, in addition, there was no provision for penalties in case of overruns. This should have led to an amendment of the contract.

74.

The second contract signed by the Commission was in response to a proposal from the same consultant, suggesting that the use of the models created under the first contract should be extended to all the CF measures, so that the consultant would be able to estimate the short, medium and long-term impact of projects on key economic variables such as income, regional growth, private investment and employment.