Thus in the case of the Lisbon water-distribution network project it was not possible to establish any link between the revenue received by the final beneficiary over all the networks and the investment financed by the CF. For the drinking-water treatment plants, the Ibiza-desalination plant project, the price of water was calculated in 1994 as 95 ESP/m3 (approximately 0,48 EUR/m3) in the CBA, whereas the real price was, for 1997, 213,84 ESP/m3 (approximately 1,07 EUR/m3). The CBA for the Limerick City Water Supply Project did not take into account private-sector revenue, which amounted to around IEP 1,2 million (approximately EUR 1,6 million) in 1997. For the same project the IRT was calculated on the basis of a 25-year period, whereas the lifetime of the associated buildings was assumed to be 50 years. Only the financial aspects were considered in the CBA of the Tralee landfill site project, which ignored the socioeconomic aspects. The Belview rail crossing project does not contain an IRT calculation and states only that economic benefits are expected in terms of time saving, without quantifying them.
The CBA for the Autoroute Pathe-F-Pont project estimated an investment cost of around EUR 4 million, whereas the construction contract signed was for an amount of some EUR 2,3 million.
This disparity between design and interpretation in relation to the application of CBAs tends to produce results which differ according to the hypotheses adopted and may distort the appraisal of the benefits or drawbacks of a given project relative to others. The Commission should be careful to draw up more precise guidelines on this point in order to harmonise the methods applied, particularly as regards the essential information that must be submitted with CBAs so that their reliability can be verified and they are comparable.
Indicators