, Special Report No 15/2000 on the Cohesion Fund, together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 6 Jul 2000

Public investment expenditure

(Gross fixed capital formation by general government as a percentage of GDP)

>TABLE>

Project development cycle

51.

The development of a project can be seen in terms of stages of a cycle and this allows tighter control over its management. In CF projects, the Commission is mainly involved at the beginning and end of the cycle. At the beginning, during the phase leading up to the approval decision, the Commission must evaluate a certain number of factors that are internal (planning, cost estimates, IRR, feasibility, performance forecasts, etc.) or external (cost-benefit analysis, desired global strategy, synergies with other projects, national or regional priorities, location, etc., to the project). At the end of the cycle the Commission must ensure that the project has been closed, approve the final implementation report and release the final balance.

52.

Between these two stages a number of events may substantially alter a project's development (unforeseen events, budget overruns, delays, incomplete initial design, unrealistic planning, etc.). These lead to amendments to the initial decision without the possibility of the Commission's intervening on a precautionary basis to correct any change of direction. The Commission finds itself obliged to accept developments that have taken place at the investment level, whereas it could have detected them at an earlier stage if it had had a better understanding of the factors influencing project costs and had subjected them to adequate controls. In addition, apart from their consequences for the extent of the outcome and impact of projects, the budget and timetable overruns ratified by the Commission absorb appropriations to the detriment of approvals of new projects. Furthermore, once the Commission has decided to approve a project, subsequent amendments to its decision are often accepted without the initial rigour and without the necessary in-depth analysis of the causes which triggered them. Examination of the documents justifying the amendments that had been requested and adopted did not always enable the factors that brought them about to be identified, or the set of solutions found.