, Special Report No 6/98 concerning the Court's assessment of the system of resources base…

In forcesince 14 May 1998

3.24. The correction of 'budgetary imbalances`, as defined by the Fontainebleau European Council, consists of reducing the negative budget balance of the Member State in question by two thirds. For a given financial year, this balance is calculated by multiplying the difference between the Member State's percentage share of VAT-GNP contributions and its percentage share of 'allocated` expenditure by the total for 'allocated expenditure` (32). This correction is financed by the other Member States.

No generalised application of the system

3.25. Even though the conclusions of the European Council of Fontainebleau state that any Member State with a budgetary imbalance in relation to its relative prosperity may apply for a correction, the current Decision on own resources only specifically grants it to one Member State.

3.26. There is therefore no generalised system enabling other Member States to benefit from such a correction, just as there is no monitoring procedure to examine that the said correction is still justified. A solution to this problem would be to amend the Decision on own resources. However, under Article 201 of the EC Treaty, any amendments to this Decision are subject to unanimous approval by the Member States and national ratification procedures.

A possible extension to other countries

3.27. Without prejudice to any comments that could be made as regards the relative prosperity of the Member States, the criteria currently applied for revenue correction would enable six other Member States to qualify. This would have resulted, on the basis of the latest definitive figures available (for the financial year 1996), in an increase of between 2 900 Mio ECU (one Member State) and 12 400 Mio ECU (seven Member States) in the total amount spent on the correction (i. e. 22 % of the VAT and GNP resources for the financial year in question).

3.28. Moreover, given that the beneficiary States do not contribute towards financing it, this correction would actually largely be financed by Member States whose per capita GNP is lower than the Community average, which is the reason why these Member States are eligible for the Structural Funds in favour of the less prosperous countries.

An inadequate definition of the notion of a budgetary imbalance