, Special Report No 6/98 concerning the Court's assessment of the system of resources base…

In forcesince 14 May 1998

4.18. As stated under 4.12 above, this difference must be considered minimal, since it reflects the greater or lesser exhaustiveness of the national accounts during the period in question. The Court notes that, in connection with the calculation of the GNP (62), Member States are required to check the exhaustiveness of their national accounts so as to give adequate attention to economic transactions relating to the underground economy. On the basis of this operation, which is to be completed by 1 October 1998 (63), it should be possible to obtain a figure that is more representative of economic reality.

4.19. If the results of the Court's calculation are compared with those of a similar calculation made by the Commission in 1989 for the 1980-1984 period, it will be noted, for the countries covered by the two enquiries at the time, that the overall difference as a percentage of revenue collected had increased by more than 60 % in ten years. This is an indication that VAT fraud is on the increase.

Theoretical VAT and the exhaustiveness of the GNP

4.20. In order to provide the Member States with a uniform framework of reference for the treatment of theoretical VAT revenue in their national accounts, the Commission plans to ask the Member States to carry out the necessary work on the treatment of theoretical VAT revenue simultaneously with the conclusion of the exercise on the exhaustiveness of the GNP. Nevertheless, at a distance of a few months from the expected conclusion date, no decision has been taken. The draft decision calls for some comments.

4.21. A method is proposed, but the Member States are free to continue to apply others on condition that they achieve comparable results. It will therefore be up to the Commission to ensure the validity of the sources and methods used as well the comparability of the results obtained.