, Special Report No 6/98 concerning the Court's assessment of the system of resources base…

In forcesince 14 May 1998

3.58. The applicable provisions (48) state that the own resources are to be paid into an account opened in the name of the Commission in each of the Member States. The Member States are required to send a statement to the Commission after each transaction, within seven working days. Practice concerning the transmission of these statements (once a day, or even after months have elapsed), as well as the indication of the payment date (value date and/or date of entry in accounts) varies considerably from one Member State to another. The result is that the Commission is not permanently informed, in a direct and independent manner, of the actual situation regarding its assets. This is contrary to the notion of an own resource and can cause cash management difficulties or even payment difficulties.

3.59. Budgetary imbalances are corrected by a detailed calculation procedure worked out by the Commission. First of all, the latter makes a calculation that takes into account the principles adopted before the 1988 Decision on own resources, when there was no GNP resource and the VAT resource was not capped. This calculation is then adjusted to take account of the current Decision on own resources. In practice, this means two calculations. As the Court observed in its Annual Report on the financial year 1991 (49), it would be simpler and more transparent to use one calculation method only.

3.60. Separating the calculation of the VAT resource from that of financing the correction would make it possible to avoid subsequent complications. The amount of the correction and the financing of it result in a substitution effect between the VAT and GNP resources, which modifies the respective shares of the Member States and must be taken into account for both the estimated and definitive calculations.

4.

THE VULNERABILITY OF THE VAT AND GNP RESOURCES

Effects of losses of tax revenue on the VAT and GNP resources

4.1. The Community's ability to meet its expenditure obligations does not depend on the degree of efficiency shown by the national authorities in collecting VAT and preventing fraud. Under the terms of the Decision on own resources, the GNP resource may in fact be used to compensate for a budgetary imbalance in the event that other resources are inadequate.