, Special Report No 6/98 concerning the Court's assessment of the system of resources base…

In forcesince 14 May 1998

3.32. The aim of this exercise was to assess the economic output flows generated both within and among the Member States by a given hypothetical piece of expenditure in their favour in the sectors of agriculture (50 % of the hypothetical expenditure), infrastructure (40 % of the expenditure) and services (10 % of the expenditure). The result was that the additional output generated by expenditure granted to a given country was not limited to the country in question, but could extend to other countries (including non-Member States) as a result of imports/exports of goods and services. Effects could also be identified in economic sectors which were not direct beneficiaries of Community payments.

3.33. The multiplier effect in terms of output generated by the expenditure was, overall, about twice as high as the expenditure itself. However, probably because of differences in the productive structures of the various countries of the Union, this effect may vary considerably from one Member State to another. In relation to expenditure, the multiplier effect is between + 48 % and + 111 %. This does seem to confirm that, in this context, the sectors where the Community intervenes do indeed determine the benefits that a country obtains from its membership of the Union. It therefore follows that it is the effects of budgetary policy choices, rather than mere financial flows, that provide the most appropriate information as to any imbalances.

The importance of statistics in the calculation of the VAT and GNP resources

3.34. Macro-economic data, deriving from national accounts statistics, on which the GNP resource is based, also play a major role in the determination of the VAT resource.

3.35. For the VAT resource, calculating the Weighted Average Rate (WAR) requires statistical data so that the weighting of the VAT rates applied to the various taxable transactions can be established. These data, which correspond to the net values of the transactions that have been carried out, are broken down by VAT rate on the basis of statistical data from the national accounts (ESA) or other sources. Nevertheless, compiling the necessary data requires practical efforts so as to reconcile the statistics on taxable transactions.