SPECIAL REPORT No 6/98 concerning the Court's assessment of the system of resources based on VAT and GNP together with the Commission's replies (submitted pursuant to the second subparagraph of Article 188c(4) of the EC Treaty) (98/C 241/02)
INTRODUCTION
1.1. This report examines the development, the workings and the limitations of the Community budget's two main sources of funds, to wit the VAT and GNP resources, which account for approximately 80 % of the Community's revenue i. e. 61 000 Mio ECU in 1997 (1). The reader is reminded that the entire system of own resources has been examined once before, in 1993 (2). Subsequent Annual Reports have also made observations on the traditional own resources, in addition to those set out in the 1993 report.
1.2. Various Court Annual Reports have also looked at several aspects of the VAT and GNP resources. In respect of the VAT resource, these aspects included, in particular, the disparity between Member States in respect of the data used for the calculation of the Weighted Average Rate (a fundamental element of the assessment base) and the various adjustments and compensations. Regarding the GNP resource, the Court's previous comments looked, in particular, at the methods and procedures used for making forecasts, the quality of the national accounts and the need for measuring instruments.
1.3. Given the scale of the phenomenon, this report also looks at the consequences for the VAT and GNP resources of the loss of tax income.
FINANCING THE COMMUNITY BUDGET
The background to the system for financing the Community
2.1. The Treaty of Paris of 18 April 1951 (3), which set up the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC), provided that the latter would be financed from levies based on coal and steel production.
2.2. In addition to these levies, which might rightly be defined as the first Community tax, there was also interest received on own funds, investments, reserves and other revenue.