3.8. The Decision on own resources states that the system of own resources must 'take into account the contributory capacity of the Member States`, which is indicated by the Gross National Product at market prices (GNP). The GNP, a derivative of the Gross Domestic Product at market prices (GDP), was chosen as an indicator of contributory capacity because it is supposed to measure the prosperity of a country and not, as is the case with GDP, its productive capacity.
3.9. However, under the Agreement on the European Economic Area (16), these countries' contributions to Community projects are determined according to their GDP. The Commission also uses GDP to assess a Member State's 'ability to pay` in connection with the obligations provided for in Article 171 of the Treaty (17). It must therefore be asked whether the notion of contributory capacity is being treated consistently, even though the contexts are different.
The system's corrective factors
The capping of the VAT assessment base
3.10. Whereas the call-up rate for the VAT resource had just been increased from 1 % to 1,4 % in 1985 to make up for the shortfall in resources, in 1988 it was decided to reduce the VAT resource's contribution to the budget and create a complementary resource based on the GNP. The intention was to take the contributory capacity of the Member States more accurately into account, and this was subsequently confirmed by the protocol on economic and social cohesion annexed to the Treaty on European Union and the current Decision on own resources.
3.11. The Commission had in fact pointed out (18) that, by its very nature as a consumption tax, the VAT resource produced a regressive effect, whereby the least prosperous Member States (with their relatively high level of consumption and low savings rate) tended to contribute more than their share of the Community GNP would warrant. This meant that the VAT resource constituted a factor of imbalance in the Member States' financing of the budget, in particular from the point of view of 'equity` (19).
3.12. The share of the VAT resource in financing the Community budget has gradually been reduced since 1988. As from 1999, the call-up rate for the VAT resource is to be limited to 1 % and the VAT base taken into consideration may not exceed 50 % of GNP (20).