, Special Report No 6/98 concerning the Court's assessment of the system of resources base…

In forcesince 14 May 1998

4.8. In the case of VAT, the national accounts enable an assessment of the size of potential losses of revenue by comparing the tax base as calculated from the national accounts with that declared to the tax authorities by registered taxpayers. Where this latter factor is not available, it is possible to carry out an indirect assessment by calculating the tax base implicitly declared on the basis of revenue collected. This procedure involves calculating the divergence between VAT revenue collected and what may be called the 'theoretical VAT`.

4.9. Despite the different approaches adopted by the Member States, the 'only reliable rule in this case is perhaps that theoretical VAT is higher than actual VAT revenue. This is the only means of guaranteeing that the national accounts have at least included a certain number of transactions that have been hidden from the tax authorities` (53).

4.10. Theoretical VAT may be defined as 'the VAT which would be produced if all units liable to pay the tax actually paid it in accordance with the relevant legislation` (54).

4.11. The discrepancy between revenue actually collected and theoretical VAT does not, in itself, constitute the amount of tax revenue lost. In actual fact neither of the two factors being compared is completely homogeneous. In particular, the figure for revenue collected is affected by bankruptcies, cancelled or deferred debts, the non-correspondence between revenue paid in and the financial year concerned. These factors are not entirely taken into account by the national accounts upon which the calculation of theoretical VAT is based.

4.12. On the other hand, the theoretical VAT is directly affected by the exhaustiveness of the national accounts and by their capacity to reflect taxable transactions which do not figure for various reasons (failure to update statistical records, shortcomings in statistical surveys, the existence of unregistered workers, cases where turnover is understated or undeclared). Furthermore, the Commission noted in 1994 (55) that 'economic activity carried out contrary to fiscal and social legislation is currently not taken into account in the Member States' estimates in a uniform manner`. It admits that the underground economy does raise a not inconsiderable problem concerning the fiscal systems at present in use (56), and that problem seems to have increased in recent decades (57).

Assessment work by the Commission and the Member States