, Special Report No 6/98 concerning the Court's assessment of the system of resources base…

In forcesince 14 May 1998

4.13. In connection with its responsibilities as regards the collection of the VAT resource, the Commission has carried out work in this field, starting in 1981. This work was gradually extended to include the effects of VAT fraud on the calculation of the GNP.

4.14. Several Member States used the calculation of theoretical VAT to assess fraud and carry out the necessary adjustments with regard to the calculation of the GNP. Estimating total fraud, in particular that for fraud 'without the complicity` of the purchaser (58), is part of the work of the GNP Committee (59).

4.15. The figures given by the Member States, in particular in connection with the work of the GNP Committee, differ considerably, depending on the methods used and the degree of exhaustiveness of the national accounts. Nevertheless, this confirms, at a factual level, that divergences between collected VAT and theoretical VAT can mainly be explained by fraud. Such divergences provide a minimal assessment of the phenomenon (see paragraph 4.12).

Assessment work by the Court

4.16. Basing itself on the methods used, in particular, by the Commission departments in 1989, the Court replicated this exercise for nine Member States for the period running from 1991 to 1993. The Court's calculation was based, in particular, on data taken from the national accounts drawn up by the Member States for the establishment of the VAT assessment base (60). It was forwarded to the Commission and the Member States concerned.

4.17. For the period in question, this calculation shows that there was a considerable difference between VAT collected and theoretical VAT (61). On a weighted basis, the overall difference was more than 1 % of the total GNP of the countries in question. It accounted for almost 21 % of the total of revenue collected by these Member States, or an annual average of approximately 70 000 Mio ECU, an amount which is almost equal to the present total for the Community budget.