, Special Report No 6/98 concerning the Court's assessment of the system of resources base…

In forcesince 14 May 1998

3.48. These reservations usually stem from problems relating to the statistical data used for the calculation of the bases, or even from cases of infringement of the legislation, in particular in respect of the application of the Sixth Directive, on the Common VAT Regime (41).

3.49. The Court has already noted, on several occasions, (42) that the resolution of outstanding cases is particularly laborious because it sometimes requires additional work. It takes several years, during which discussions are held with the Member States. This is shown by the fact that, although the Commission declared, in 1991, that it would lift the reservations two years after its checks, six years later it declared this commitment to have been unrealistic (43).

3.50. In the notification of reservations for the VAT resource, no account is taken of the fact that, for certain Member States whose assessment base has been reduced by capping, reservations that might increase the base will for this reason have no effect. Except where work undertaken in this connection is likely to bring about improvements in other fields (statistics, tax legislation), the point of these procedures is not clear.

3.51. When an agreement is found as to the corrections that need to be made, this modifies the Member States' respective contributions to the Community budget for several financial years previously. In 1997, corrections were made as far back as the financial year 1982. These corrections are generally not subject to interest on arrears, which, however, should be charged given the delays that occur in the resolution of outstanding cases.

3.52. However, corrections of the assessment base in connection with budgetary imbalances are only taken into account up to the financial year n+4, that is to say when the correction is adopted definitively. Consequently, the latter cannot be affected by corrections beyond this time limit.

An imprecise legal framework

3.53. The legal framework governing the VAT and GNP resources is not precise. Some examples are given below.

Adaptation of the regulations on the VAT resource