, Special Report No 6/98 concerning the Court's assessment of the system of resources base…

In forcesince 14 May 1998

4.2. However, as the Commission has pointed out (50), these differences in degree of efficiency are not without effects on the Community's finances. Tax evasion and underground economic activities may affect both VAT income and the calculation of the GNP unless suitable adjustments are made. Consequently, this could affect not only the financial breakdown among Member States, but also the maximum ceiling of budgetary resources which is established as a percentage of GNP.

4.3. The components of the VAT assessment base are also at the base of taxpayers' declarations for direct taxation and social security contribution purposes. The amounts at stake in these cases, moreover, are much higher than for VAT (51) alone, which may therefore constitute the main reason for the fraud. As a consequence, a simultaneous VAT fraud results from the need for the taxpayer's accounts to be consistent and the VAT fraud is therefore no more than a component of a more general loss of tax revenue.

The inherent risks of the VAT system

4.4. Under the VAT system, taxpayers in principle have an interest in insisting on invoices so as to be able to deduct the VAT. This is why the Commission has stated that VAT is an 'inherently self-policing` tax (52).

4.5. In actual fact, a taxpayer who wants to reduce the tax base to be declared (which, as shown under 4.3 above, is linked to that used for other taxes and social charges) has various ways of 'justifying` the plausibility of his accounts in the event of an audit.

4.6. In particular, the mechanism of deducting the input tax may induce taxpayers to declare undue production costs, backed, for example, by presenting formally irreproachable documents which, however, do not correspond to any economic reality or to any actual transactions. This concerns, in particular, false invoices. Such undue costs are difficult to detect because of the need for detailed cross-checks between a number of taxpayers.

4.7. In view of the financial stakes involved, presumed conflicting interests between taxpayers are not enough to guarantee compliance with the tax legislation. Compliance is more the product of other factors (public spiritedness, efficient checks, clear simple legislation, tax levels) than the supposed self-regulating machinery of the VAT system.

Ways of assessing losses of VAT income