3.13. In the Commission's opinion, the VAT resource does not represent the contributory capacity of the Member States and it even considers it to be inequitable - even after correction by capping. However, this resource has not been abolished and replaced by an increase in the GNP resource, although this would have been possible when the GNP resource was created in 1988.
3.14. Furthermore, even with the establishment of a capping ceiling at 50 % of GNP as from 1999, the bases of certain Member States will not be capped. Moreover, as the Court observed in its Opinion No 8/93, it is not necessarily the least prosperous Member States that benefit from this capping, even though the re-balancing of the resources was intended to benefit them.
3.15. The capping of the VAT resource introduced an element of distortion into the system. Some Member States (four in 1998) contribute to the budget purely in accordance with their contributory capacity (GNP), as a result of the capping of their VAT bases, while others contribute on the twofold basis of their contributory capacity and taxable consumption (VAT). However, as the Court has already noted (21), the call-up rate for the VAT resource is based on the principle that it should apply in the same way to everybody. Moreover, a reduction in the share of the budget financed by the VAT resource could have been achieved without calling into question the generalised application of this principle, simply by reducing the call-up rate.
3.16. The VAT resource poses a problem of consistency. If it is to be considered a contribution by the Member States, it should logically have been abolished in 1988 and replaced by the GNP resource. If, on the other hand, it is meant to be a tax on the final consumption of European citizens, capping it in accordance with GNP may reasonably be questioned. Indeed, in the latter case, it should be considered a genuine own resource, and capping it would therefore not be justified because that would nullify its primary function.
Towards a twofold GNP