4.26. The question also arises as to how the national accounts can adequately take into account fraud perpetrated by registered taxpayers. However, the Commission Decision and the debates within the GNP Committee provide only partial answers.
CONCLUSIONS
A question that must be addressed
5.1. Although it has made it possible to continue financing the budget under acceptable conditions, the VAT and GNP resource system is characterized by problems of consistency and transparency, as well as operational shortcomings, which should be addressed as soon as possible. This discussion is all the more urgent from the viewpoint of the enlargement of the European Union.
5.2. The structure and operation of the current system, which is just as detailed as a traditional budgetary system based on tax revenue, therefore seem disproportionate in relation to the nature of the VAT and GNP resources. A system of financial contributions does not call for the innumerable complications of the current system.
5.3. The presence of a form of revenue correction constitutes another anomaly of the system. Its conceptual basis, consisting in identifying the benefit that a Member State gains from its membership of the Union by calculating the difference between the money it pays in and that which it receives, is questionable. As the Fontainebleau European Council suggested, any imbalances should be corrected via expenditure policy. In actual fact, the time when political budgetary choices are made, when the Council and the Parliament are involved in their roles as budgetary authorities, is the right moment to direct the effects of Community funding, including geographically.
5.4. Furthermore, tax evasion, which is growing in an alarming fashion, and which must be fought first and foremost by the Member States, directly affects the establishment of the VAT and GNP assessment bases and may also affect the calculation of the GNP and therefore also the GNP resource itself.
Ambiguities that must be cleared up
5.5. Situations like that of the VAT resource, which started out as a tax but, in reality, has taken on the nature of a financial contribution, should be avoided. A resource based on the taxable consumption of citizens only has a raison d'ëtre if it is based directly on a tax base declared by the taxpayers. It should also take into account the various factors making for losses of tax resources and endow the Union with suitable corrective instruments.