4.22. The need to ensure that the data are completely comparable also applies to those Member States which are able to show that an equivalent calculation is already implicitly included in their national accounts, which will entitle them to be exempted from the exercise required under the terms of Article 4 of the draft Decision. Furthermore, in this connection, it should be remembered that Commission Directive No 89/130/EEC, Euratom and Commission Decision No 94/168/EC, Euratom of 22 February 1994 (64) already state that adjustments ensuring the exhaustiveness of the GNP should be backed by appropriate calculations. The Commission should already be in a position to check these calculations.
4.23. The draft Commission Decision requires the Member States to make a distinction between fraud 'without complicity` (of the purchaser) and fraud 'with complicity` (65). The latter is defined as being perpetrated by economically active units that are not listed in the statistical records and carry out transactions without collecting and paying over VAT.
4.24. However, in the real economic world, it does not seem to be possible to distinguish between types of fraud in such a clear-cut fashion. In particular, it is difficult to establish whether the price paid for a transaction corresponds to a market price with or without VAT. It is possible for the purchaser not to make a profit where the price paid to the seller is actually equivalent to the price inclusive of VAT. This depends, in particular, on the equilibrium price between supply and demand. Consequently, distinguishing between fraud 'without (purchaser) complicity` and fraud 'with complicity` raises difficulties which neither the Member States nor the Commission can evade.
4.25. According to this draft Decision, registered taxpayers would not be involved in fraud 'with complicity`. However, as discussions within the GNP Committee have shown, this is questionable. In actual fact, registered and unregistered taxpayers alike may, with the agreement of the purchaser, carry out sales exclusive of VAT even though they are intended for final consumption. They may also connive to increase their tax deduction rights unduly by over-assessing their intermediate costs, where necessary via false invoices.