3.3. According to the Commission 'the methods used to finance the Community budget illustrate the political development of the Community. Thus, in the beginning, the Community was financed by financial contributions from the Member States based on fixed percentages (Article 200 of the EC Treaty)` (10). This system was to be replaced by own resources (Article 201 of the EC Treaty). These own resources therefore took the form of taxes that were levied directly on natural and legal persons within the Community. They were independent of the decisions of the Member States and there was an automatic link between the Community and its source of revenue, i. e. all economic transactions liable to Community taxation.
3.4. The original plan of making the VAT resource a tax based directly on consumption, or, at least, on taxpayers' declarations, was subsequently abandoned (11) as a result, in particular, of the differing ways the VAT legislation is applied in the Member States. The practical procedures for calculating this resource (12) confirm the fact that it is a national contribution (13). This resource derives from a tax that is not borne by taxpayers; instead it represents a debt on the part of the Member States.
3.5. Contrary to the Commission's 1988 statement, even though the VAT resource is based on the first tax to be harmonised at a European level, it may be doubted that it has had 'an undoubted political and psychological impact` (14). In fact, its link to fiscal reality is very tenuous, in particular because the calculation of the VAT resource involves considerable use of statistical sources.
3.6. Moreover, the progressive capping of the VAT assessment base as a percentage of GNP with effect from 1988 has on the one hand helped to reduce the significance of the VAT resource in the financing of the budget and, on the other hand, it has accentuated the resource's macro-economic character via its link with the GNP.
3.7. Though the GNP resource is certainly not fiscal in nature, the situation is not very different for the VAT resource. This is so despite the fact that 'the system of VAT resources was designed to provide a source of Community financing that ensures a direct link between the European taxpayers and the Community budget` (15).
The contributory capacity of the Member States