5.6. With regard to the GNP, the fact of not linking the GNP resource to the most up-to-date form of the GNP (the 1995 version of the ESA), as recent developments show, would make it impossible for it to mirror the contributory capacity of the Member States. Furthermore, the need to guarantee equivalent sources, methods and calculation procedures in the Member States means that the GNP must be evaluated in the light of instruments for measuring the quality of the national accounts. Such instruments ought to ensure that the GNP enjoys the legitimacy that the various uses to which it is put within the European Union require.
A choice that must be made: a consistent and transparent system
5.7. The history of the financing of the European Communities is sufficiently long to provide specific examples and practical experience with regard to the system that needs to be developed for the future.
5.8. This debate must provide a clear definition of the nature of the resources that should be allocated to the Community budget. It is not up to the Court to point out the possible choices. The implications of these choices are not neutral, for either the Member States or the Commission. The Court feels, however, that the precepts behind any system of financing must be clearly stated and there must be consistency between the nature of the resources selected and the methods used for collecting and auditing them.
5.9. Any new system should be simple, practical, related to the Member States' ability to pay and transparent. It should also be in accordance with the nature of the resources chosen.
A stable system that can be audited
5.10. The system to be selected must be able to guarantee the funds needed for financing Community policies in the long term. In particular, repeated changes in the legal framework should be avoided. In the recent past, the framework of the Decision on own resources was changed three times in ten years.
5.11. Lastly, the system must offer guarantees and procedures to make it both reliable and auditable. What is at stake is the confidence in it of those who are called upon to finance it, and the possibility of accounting to the taxpayers for its functioning and its compliance with the objectives upon which it is based.
This report was adopted by the Court of Auditors in Luxembourg at the Court meeting of 13 and 14 May 1998.
For the Court of Auditors
Bernhard FRIEDMANN
President