3.44. During the implementation of the budgetary procedure, the Commission establishes estimates of the VAT and GNP bases. Independently of exchange variations between national currencies and the ECU, differences, sometimes significant differences, have been noted compared with the actual bases. During the 1989-1995 period, for the VAT resource, the maximum divergences between estimated and actual bases were between - 5 % and + 9 % for the Member States as a whole. For the GNP resource, this same divergence was between - 6 % and + 3 %. As overall resources available for financial year n, as determined at the beginning of the year n-1 on the basis of an estimate of the Community's GNP, are not rectified during year n, the quality of the estimates is particularly important.
3.45. It is questionable whether the forecasting procedure, which involves administrative costs, should be preserved under the current system of financial contributions. Some thought could be given to replacing it with the use of definitive (even old) data, with results that would be at least as close to reality as those achieved via the estimates. The data used could then be based on mean values in order to avoid cyclical and short-term effects, and on a sufficient number of financial years. This principle had already been applied to the system of own resources until 1987, when not all the Member States had set up their VAT systems (40).
Rectifications of the bases
3.46. The VAT and GNP assessment bases are rectified in two ways: on the one hand corrections are made on the basis of the real assessment bases at the end of the year following the financial year in question (see paragraph 3.47). On the other hand, multiple corrections are carried out following audits by the Commission.
3.47. Where the Commission judges an aspect of the calculation of the base to be incorrect, it lodges a reservation, which enables, where necessary, the necessary adjustments to be made for the current financial year as well as for the previous accounting periods. In addition, Member States are also entitled to lodge reservations. At the end of the financial year 1997, there were 117 reservations for the VAT resource and 120 for the GNP resource, the majority of which concerned the exhaustiveness of the GNP.