As far as the legal provisions of the protocols are concerned, the Third Protocols were implemented in the absence of an adequate legal base and Council Regulations (EC) No 1762/92 and No 1488/96 were adopted without preliminary consultation of the Court of Auditors by the legislator, although this requirement is stipulated in Article 209 of the EC Treaty.
OPERATIONS MANAGED DIRECTLY BY THE COMMISSION
In this section of the report key findings are presented concerning the instruments and resources which the Commission uses for the management and monitoring of projects. The weaknesses identified help to explain some of the problems and difficulties encountered in the implementation of the projects, at the level of the Commission and at that of project management on the spot.
Management and monitoring instruments
The financing agreements
In the context of the operations examined by the Court, the financing agreement (FA) is the basic document for the implementation of projects (12). It formalises the culmination of the preparatory phase and its importance is determined by the following points:
the agreement constitutes a legal act which sets out the obligations of the signatories;
as a management instrument, the agreement, amongst other things, specifies the objectives to be achieved and the project's management structures, describes the implementing procedures and specifies the procedures for monitoring the operations and evaluating the results;
on the financial level, the agreement fixes the project's overall budget and defines the appropriations allocated to each of the identified expenditure headings.
In its previous reports, the Court pointed out the considerable weaknesses of the financing agreements drawn up by the Commission (13), weaknesses which were confirmed during this audit. Examination of these agreements has shown, in fact, that for most of them:
neither the general nor the specific objectives which the project sets out to achieve are clearly defined or quantified. How the expected results are to be achieved from the means made available is not defined sufficiently clearly. The consequence is that the final evaluation of the projects' success is made more difficult;