, Special Report No 1/98 in respect of bilateral financial and technical cooperation with…

In forcesince 29 Jan 1998
71.

On this last point, the Court noted that the Commission now has a tendency to include in the text of the FA an obligation to accept external audits. The Commission should, however, define the objectives of these audits sufficiently precisely and improve the follow-up in order to draw maximum benefit from them and avoid situations like those met with in the Nile Valley Regional Project (SEM/03/220/008A). In spite of annual audits over five years of implementation, the excessive invoicing of administrative costs (see paragraph 64) by the technical assistance units was never noticed.

Amendments to the initial decisions

72.

Examination of the files has shown that major amendments, or transfers of appropriations from one budget heading to another, were accepted by the Delegations, the management units or the technical assistance units without the Commission having delegated authority to these various units to do this. In addition, these amendments took place without any written explanation which would have allowed checks to be carried out to see whether they were really justified.

Major amendments

73.

Within the framework of the project concerning the loan operations in favour of small and medium-sized agricultural enterprises in Tunisia (SEM/03/212/015), the type of the products to be imported, as stipulated in the FA, was ignored and essential products of a different type, to a value of almost 11 Mio ECU, were imported. The Delegation also accepted a substantial increase in the rates of interest on the medium-term and long-term loans, raising them from 7,50 to 10 % and from 8 to 11 %. This last amendment increased the farmers' debt burden considerably and a number of them were not able to support it (see paragraph 97).

74.

Within the framework of the agricultural development project to the south-west of Kef in Tunisia (SEM/03/212/004), the management powers delegated by the FA to a body with legal personality and budgetary autonomy were transferred to a decentralised administration which was not at liberty to invest liquid assets.