, Special Report No 1/98 in respect of bilateral financial and technical cooperation with…

In forcesince 29 Jan 1998
124.

Apart from these two weaknesses, the quality of the appraisal files varies. An examination of files appraised by the EIB's offices directly, or by the Tunisian IFI, or by the investment company created in Morocco, shows the high quality of the appraisal work. In contrast, the poor quality of the files forwarded in support of applications for the allocation of funds by the other IFIs visited as part of the inquiry, reflects, depending on the individual case, the absence or lack of experience on the part of these institutions in the management of this type of operation.

Concentration of aid

125.

Of the eight projects selected in Tunisia, the IFI was itself the beneficiary for half of them, receiving an amount in excess of more than 60 % of the total allocation.

126.

In Morocco, according to information received from the supervisory authorities, the beneficiaries of the risk capital came mainly from amongst the usual customers of the IFIs.

127.

In Egypt, three projects absorbed 16,5 Mio ECU of the 27 Mio made available under the Third and Fourth Protocols. This concentration of allocations is also special because of the size of the projects financed, one of them representing a total investment of 140 Mio ECU, of the size of the European partners involved, the majority of which are multinational companies, and of the commitment by the EIB of its own resources in these operations.

128.

Such concentrations are questionable, in spite of the undeniable economic importance of the projects financed in Egypt in the light of the objectives laid down for risk capital by the Protocols and indicative programmes concluded with these countries. The fact is that, according to the terms of the latter, small and medium-sized enterprises constitute the favoured target group for risk capital. However, the only operations aimed at benefiting these enterprises were financed by two global loans, of which the first, under the Third Protocol, was only partially used and the second, under the Fourth Protocol, had not been the subject of any allocation at the time of the Court's audit.

129.

According to the EIB, the portfolio of projects financed in Egypt is sound and reflects its concern to manage the resources entrusted to it by the Commission as well as possible, taking into account the possibilities offered by the local market. Without disputing this claim, the Court notes a contradiction with the commitments made in the indicative programmes.